Data-Driven Decisions: Turning Insight Into Action | TMC 2026

More data doesn't always lead to better decisions. Kim Voon and Clara explore how businesses can turn performance data and customer insight into meaningful action.

We're collecting more data than ever, but are we actually making better decisions because of it?

At Insight Online, we look at performance data every day. But the numbers only tell part of the story. You also need to understand the people behind them and what’s happening in the business.

In this talk, Clara from Remade and I look at how data, customer understanding and creative thinking can work together to help businesses make better decisions.

‍

Transcript:

Clara: My name's Clara, I run Remade, which is a creative agency here in Auckland. And this is my friend Kim, who runs Insight Online.

So while you're enjoying your afternoon tea, we've decided that we're going to tell you a couple of stories.

As Lisa mentioned today, like we've heard a lot about AI data, insights, growth, and tech. And what we are going to do is talk to you about what happens once you get all of that information, because more information doesn't necessarily help you make better decisions.

So at Remade, I'm really fortunate to lead a team of really smart humans, and we take our understanding of other humans and use it to turn it into something that they will notice, that they'll find interesting, and hopefully they'll act on.

Kim: And this is Kim. And I run Insight Online.

I run Insight Online. And we're a performance agency that focusses on lead generation, mainly for B2C businesses.

And I think in our world, we are surrounded by quantitative data. And if we have all the clicks and metrics you could ever want, CTR, CPC, average position, share of search, and the thing about it is, if you ever run short of a metric, we just take one, divide by another, new metric.

And I think the thing is that often, with the work that Clara does and the work that I do, we're often put on opposite sides somehow, when in fact, the brand and strategy and performance, we are so complementary in what we do.

And actually, I found it tremendously heartening today how I think the theme that I got was, we're pushing more towards what makes us unique and what makes us human.

And I love that. I love that about today.

So Clara has got a terrific story to share with us about our main point, and that's that insights alone don't create advantage, it's about what we do with it.

And so, over to Clara.

‍

Part 1: Clara's Story

Clara: Thanks so much, Kim. So I'm gonna take you through a story about how insight guided our journey for one of our clients and what they did with it.

Now, New Zealand, as you may know, has kind of lagged behind the rest of the world when it comes to modern slavery legislation. And that has had an impact on our reputation in international trade, as well as human rights.

So our client was Fair and Good, and they're an ethical charity. And their huge ambition is to help people identify truly ethical products, so that when they purchase these products, that will have an impact on the supply chains of other companies who maybe aren't so ethical.

So to do this, they established a directory that had about 50 or more ethical brands and products.

And at the start, it seemed like they had a comms problem. They just needed people to know that they were there.

But actually, when you think about it, it was a behaviour problem that they were having. Because in order to achieve their goals, we needed a lot of people to start buying differently.

The challenge wasn't getting across another fact. It was deciding which facts we should change what we did.

‍So imagine the customer journey, and I think we've all been in this situation.

You're in the supermarket, you're shopping online, you've got a million things on your mind and absolutely no time to get the shop actually done.

In that very moment, are you really gonna pick up a product and go, hang on, is the supply chain ethical? Probably not.

And yet research told us that 50% of people actually care how workers are treated. And yet 67% of them cannot tell if a product is ethical.

Our client had over 50 plus brands and services on their website that were gonna satisfy that desire to shop ethically. But the behaviour data told a different story.

Most of the people who are coming to the website were over 65, and over 15% of them were actually clicking through to purchase anything.

And this is despite being number one in SEO rankings for ethical brands. Engagement was weak, even though every single fact here is true. None of them on its own was the insight.

So what didn't add up?

Fair and Good existed to make ethical shopping easier, but had they actually solved the problem that they thought they had?

Remember, you've got to go to the site, you've got to visit it, you've got to choose something, then you've got to click through. It actually seemed like there were quite a few barriers there.

So the barrier actually wasn't the intention of shopping ethically, it was the action of shopping. So the process itself had potentially created, or it had created, a significant barrier.

They were trying to make shopping easier, but they were making people work harder at that very moment that they were making those purchase decisions.

So another issue that we discovered was scale.

You know, if ambition equals mass adoption, and they needed lots of buying occasions that they could impact, so many more than the 50 plus brands that they currently had on their website.

They needed to be able to achieve their scale to impact multiple, multiple more shopping occasions. With their existing range, it was quite boutique and quite niche.

So was the product that they had developed actually capable of achieving their aim?

Now, sometimes the insight tells you that, you know, what you think you're doing and what you're actually doing are not the same thing, and I think that's kind of what we had here.

So we asked our client a really tough question:

Does what you're doing need to change, or does your ambition need to change? Because both of these things are valid.

You know, what they had built on their existing directory was actually really lovely. There were lots of really niche, gorgeous brands that were so hard to find, and they'd shone a spotlight on them.

So they could have stuck with that.

They went away, and they decided that, no, their ambition was too close to their heart. They really wanted to help people change their unethical supply chains and convert them to more ethical sourcing.

So they decided to stick with their original mission.

Then we went back to the cons.

We knew people wanted to shop more ethically, so it was the obvious answer just to sell the directory harder. But that would potentially leave the barrier in exactly the same place as it was.

Then our strategist asked, how do we get the lowest hanging fruit at volume? Like, if the mission is scale, then the solution has to be ease.

It needs to be as easy as possible for people to actually act and shop their values. So the strategy became to prove fair and good finds the ethical products for you.

The insight showed us the problem, but it hadn't yet given us the answer.

Then the brief moved to creative. And after a bit, creative asked a really key question:

Instead of bringing more people to the directory, should we bring the directory to the people?

And that was the creative leap that led to our solution that was called Find Fear.

And there's a little film about that. And there's a little film about that.

[VIDEO: FIND FEAR]

Most Kiwis are horrified to learn that some of the goods that we consume are produced through modern slavery and serious worker exploitation.

Around about $30 to $40 worth of the average household's spend each week could potentially be produced through modern slavery.

Introducing Find Fear, a new Chrome extension you add to your browser to instantly spot the ethical brands.

Find Fear works across each of the major supermarkets, four different search engines, and other popular marketplaces.

Industry changemakers were quick to lend support.

I'm such an advocate for what Find Fear is about, the educational value it delivers and the powerful outcomes it will generate.

When I first heard about this technology, I was super happy to lend my support.

Every brand has been measured against a set of nine values.

To do this, Fear and Good worked with other trusted non-profits.

We vote for the world we want through the things we buy.

Find Fear is free, easy to use, and it's a trusted third-party source.

Brands can't pay to be included. We have to endorse them.

Launched for Human Rights Day, it took off with brands and shoppers spreading the news.

There's this amazing new tool called Find Fear, a groundbreaking innovative use of technology is making it easier for New Zealanders to purchase ethical goods online.

If you want to help end slavery by shopping ethically, now you know what to look for.

Clara: So the insight didn't just change what we said, it also changed what we built.

Find Fear put the directory inside the shopping journey, right from consideration through to purchase because it worked during search as well as in-store at supermarkets and other places.

So right at the point where the decisions were happening, and the results really showed the benefit of doing that.

Really quickly, around twice the volume of people that were using the previous directory were suddenly engaging with the Chrome extension, and 80% of them were using it every single week.

So when you think about someone going to the directory website every once in a while, here it was, part of their browsing, and they were engaging with it every time they got on Chrome, basically.

And so you're just impacting so much more their buying behaviour. So that frequency really, really mattered. It increased the reach and the frequency at the same time.

So it's exactly what our client wanted. They wanted more people making more ethical choices more often.

The numbers gave us the evidence, but they didn't hand us the answer.

It was our understanding of human behaviour coupled with the numbers that we received that allowed us to create the insight that was going to really connect with people and allow the behaviour change to happen and allow people to actually act on their desire to shop more ethically.

Our client was prepared to act on it. You know, you've got to give them great credit for that. Wow, they were really ballsy. And it paid off for them, you know.

So we changed the product and the scale of behaviour that we could influence, which was great.

 And speaking of scale, I'll hand you over to Kim, who has another story around that.

I can't imagine how brave it was for them to change. Incredibly.

Because it started with Kim.

‍

Part 2: Kim's Story

Kim: Thank you for that.

I'm going to be embarrassed to tell the story, but I'm going to tell it to you guys. I'm committed now.

My story is about how dashboards, metrics can look amazing on a dashboard and mean absolutely nothing in real life.

I've had to change the name of my client to Mike, but I swear everything else is true.

Now Mike runs a Australian-based healthcare business. I didn't know this at the time. He's got about 54 clinics all over Australia.

All right. The first time I met Mike was a couple of years ago, and I was a ringer.

Mike had apparently scared off the last Google Ads guy, and I was called in 10 minutes before to just, and my mate was like, Kim, just please come in. It'll take 10, 15 minutes of your time. You just need someone to look at his Google Ads account. It'll be fast.

And I was like, sure. This guy has given me a lot of work, of course. Of course I'll jump in.

And Mike is, I would say he's maybe a classic Australian entrepreneur, and he is like a bull at the gate.

He comes in hot, jumps on the call.

"I need to know exactly what this Google Ads is doing for me. Is this even worth it? What is this platform?"

And I was like, whoa, whoa. Okay, let's take a back step here.

Just, can you tell me what it is that you actually want to do? How does this fit in with your goals? What are the decisions that you're wanting to make?

Let me stop here.

Now, I wasn't just trying to be a dick.

Clear goals filter out irrelevance, right?

And if I'm gonna jump into anyone's performance account, the performance marketers here know there are hundreds of metrics in there.

You need to know what decisions you're gonna make, what goal you want to filter it all out, all right?

So Mike pauses, reassesses. I can see him thinking, and then he's like, okay.

"I'm scaling my healthcare business. I think we have a limited window to do this. So what I'm looking for is to understand whether Google Ads can be a channel for me, all right?"

I was like, okay, there's no problem. I can do that, yeah, yeah.

So I jump into his Google Ads account, and I have a look, and it's new, maybe two, three months. If you know, you know.

And it's two, three months. His total leads are going up month on month, and his cost per lead was about $90.

And I was like, look, does $90 work for you as a cost per lead?

And he's like, yeah, no, no, I can. That's fine, I can make money off that.

I was like, okay, great. Well then, in my opinion, your account is going fine. Just leave it, just let it run. It just needs more time. Be patient, it'll be fine.

Mike says thanks and just hangs up straight away.

So I suppose he had a clear goal, right? He got the info that he needed, and he just kind of moved right along.

He calls back six months later.

"Hey Kim, can you take over our Google Ads?"

What?

"Yeah, yeah, just take them over. You guys do that, right?"

So, okay. Now, for context, it's not every day that a 50 location nationwide Australian business walks through the door and is a client for us.

You know, like, they have a straightforward goal though. Drive growth, it seems simple enough.

But this is a big deal, this is big for us.

So, we run through our normal discovery process. We launch these campaigns, we get it all up, and then we check the tracking, all right, appointment tracking, yep, that's working.

Okay, great. Then we push it live.

The campaigns go really well. In fact, after a few months, we're beating the previous agency, you know? And there's a lot of pride in that.

Let me just show you the actual Google Ads graph.

All right, there's a lot of pride in that. All the metrics are green.

And of course, Mike, aggressive Australian business owner, he wants to scale, all right?

So, we sit down to work out, okay, for each centre, how many leads is each one getting? For each lead, for each service, you know, how many leads are we getting there so we can really tune this machine?

So, we start sitting down and looking through his business data.

And I can't find the leads.

This doesn't make sense.

You know, we look through his website, his forms, the tracking, yep, that's working. The appointments, yep, that's working.

What's going on? Why can't I find the site? It doesn't make any sense.

Mike's on the phone, you know?

"I can't see the leads."

Yeah, I know.

I don't know what to tell him. You know, I'm sitting there, I'm gutted, I'm coarse.

I'm sure some of you have had that amazing feeling of success suddenly change just to be something cold and heavy in your gut.

That was what was happening to me the more and more we dug into his data.

But then, on the core, something, maybe common sense, hits me.

And I said, okay, hey, actually, if we're delivering 250 leads a month, okay, across 54 clinics, that's about roughly five leads per clinic, right?

And he's like, yeah. And it's about one lead a week.

So, if there's like five, six services per clinic, are you gonna notice that?

Shit. Shit.

We'd moved too fast, you know?

Looking at the model that we'd built for him, it just wasn't right.

We hadn't considered what it would look like for the scale of Mike's business. It was obvious that the integration between the tracking and his business data wasn't good enough.

You know, there was a clear discrepancy between what we're seeing in leads, yay, green, what he's seeing in leads, eh, meh.

So, what do you do?

All right, we have reached the impasse.

When we saw that the model wouldn't work, we went through, I think, a lot of rounds of debate about what we should be doing.

But at the end of the day, I think, realising that we had built an incorrect model, I felt that we had to kind of start again. So, we turned off the ads.

Now, I think Mike would have let us push on for a few more months, but I think we would have been in exactly the same position in a few months' time.

We needed to actually figure out what was going on.

Mike's on the phone again. I laid out for him. You guys can imagine now what he's like.

Yeah, I laid all out a problem, solution, recommendation, next steps, and an option to hand back the accounts. And I want to get this right, because it's...

And he says to me, "Mate, what are you doing? You found the problem, you found the solution, you're working on the next steps, just let's get back to work, we've both messed up here."

I'm like, wow, okay, all right. So, that's what we had to do.

We had to go small so that we could go big.

We had to think about, and of course the issue is variability, right? There were too many variables in the mix for his budget for that size of a nationwide campaign.

So, we had to pull it all the way back. So, we just pulled back to Victoria. We chose a couple of clinics there that we knew kept their business CRM quite updated, because business CRM is a little old, I'll be nice about it. But they kept their business data updated really well.

We drilled down to two services per clinic. We made sure that we were tracking appointments, sure, but also tracking calls now as well.

And we made sure that there was a Power BI report that would come out every couple of weeks, every week, sorry, so that we could get real-time information on what was happening with those two businesses.

And we set a trial period, 90 days, and we'll stop and we'll review. We weren't going to make the same mistake twice.

I think we got a bit lucky with Client Mike.

I have been in those rooms when the conversation has definitely gone hard the other way. I'm sure we all have.

But that's not the point of this story.

The point of this story is, it's not about having the best data or insights. It's about what you're willing to do with them, and that counts.

So Clara and I, we have shared two different lenses.

Actually, I think we have a very, very similar methodology.

In her case, for fair and good, their insight changed their entire product, and we changed our decision to scale. We brought it all the way back.

And I think the steps that we took, if I think about them, it's about, hey, what do we actually want to achieve, and what are the decisions that we want to take to get there?

And then letting, once we get those insights in, letting that change our decision, and then third, and I think most importantly, acting on it.

Because these days, as the other amazing speakers have mentioned, we are drowning.

I'm sure all of you, I'm 100% sure all of you are sitting on more insights, more data than you can ever use.

But alone, it's not gonna give us the edge, right? It's not gonna give us the edge.

The value of it is what we're prepared to do differently because of it. That's where the gold is.

Thank you. Thank you."

Share this post
Kim Voon
Kim founded Insight Online to bring clarity to digital marketing. With over 15 years’ experience, he guides marketers through a complex, changing digital world.

Want instant updates when we release new blogs?

Never miss out again - sign up to our newsletter. Get the latest news, resources and marketing tips straight to your inbox. We won’t share your details or spam you. Unsubscribe anytime.

By clicking Sign Up you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.